/ Blog
Home Blog Contact Buddy Ads Builder Audit Engine

Does Quality Score Still Matter in 2024?

Bidding & Smart Bidding

Quality Score still matters in 2024. The visible 1–10 metric is a lagging diagnostic, but its three underlying components — Expected CTR, Ad Relevance, and Landing Page Experience — are re-evaluated at every auction and directly influence how much you pay per click. Weak quality signals force you to overbid to stay competitive; strong ones lower your effective cost floor across every bidding strategy.

Key takeaways

  • The 1–10 Quality Score you see in the dashboard is a delayed snapshot; the real-time quality evaluation happens fresh at every auction and directly sets your Ad Rank. [1]
  • Keywords at QS 1–3 can cost 25–400% more per click than a QS 10 competitor bidding a fraction of your max CPC — a gap that compounds across thousands of auctions per day.
  • Smart Bidding amplifies your existing quality foundation; it cannot fix structural relevance problems and will overpay or collapse impression share when quality is weak. [2]
  • Landing Page Experience is the most neglected component and often the fastest to improve — mobile page speed fixes alone have moved keywords from QS 5 to QS 7–8 in accounts I manage.
  • Performance Max doesn't surface keyword-level Quality Scores, but asset quality ratings operate on the same underlying principle — treat "Low"-rated assets as your PMax equivalent of a poor QS. [3]
Key terms
Quality Score
A 1–10 diagnostic metric Google uses to summarize how relevant your keyword, ad, and landing page are to a user's search query.
Ad Rank
The score Google calculates at each auction to determine your ad's position and the price you pay, based on bid, auction-time quality, and contextual signals.
Expected CTR (eCTR)
Google's prediction of how likely your ad is to be clicked for a given query, benchmarked against historical CTR for that keyword across all advertisers.
Landing Page Experience
Google's rating of how relevant, fast, and trustworthy your post-click page is relative to the ad and query that triggered it.
Weighted Quality Score
An impressions-weighted average of Quality Scores across all keywords in an account, used to benchmark overall account efficiency.
---

Why do some practitioners say Quality Score is dead?

The skepticism is understandable, and it comes up regularly in the r/PPC community — including in this thread. Early Google Ads ran on a clean formula: Ad Rank = Max CPC × Quality Score. Every layer Google added — auction-time signals, extension impact, device context, query nuance — made the visible QS metric feel less like a live control panel and more like a trailing indicator. That frustration is legitimate.

But the logical leap from "the displayed number lags" to "quality doesn't matter" is expensive. The score shown in your interface is a diagnostic snapshot updated periodically. The underlying components it summarizes are computed dynamically at every auction using machine learning. Dismissing the metric because it lags is like ignoring your car's temperature gauge because it doesn't update in real time — the engine is still overheating.

If you've seen a Google Ads rep tell you to ignore Quality Score, that advice is specifically about not obsessing over the integer — it is not a claim that the underlying quality components stop influencing your costs.

Key Insight: The 1–10 score is a delayed diagnostic. The three components it reflects — Expected CTR, Ad Relevance, and Landing Page Experience — are evaluated fresh at every single auction. Improving them moves your real-time Ad Rank even before the displayed number updates.
---

How does Ad Rank actually work in 2024?

Ad Rank determines your auction position and the price you pay, and quality remains a core input. [4] Google's current formula is best understood as:

Ad Rank = Bid × Auction-Time Quality × Expected Impact of Extensions & Formats × Contextual Signals

The "Auction-Time Quality" component maps to the three visible dimensions: [1]

Each component is rated Below Average, Average, or Above Average — and each rating has measurable cost consequences. The table below reflects patterns from accounts I've managed over years of analysis:

Quality Score Range Typical CPC Impact vs. QS 7 What It Usually Signals
1–3 +25% to +400% higher CPC Severe relevance or landing page mismatch
4–6 +10% to +25% higher CPC Moderate gaps in relevance or CTR
7 (benchmark) Baseline Acceptable relevance across components
8–9 −10% to −20% lower CPC Strong relevance, healthy CTR signals
10 −20% to −50% lower CPC Exceptional match between ad, query, and landing page

A keyword sitting at QS 3 that you're forcing into an auction with a $5 bid is effectively paying the same as a QS 10 competitor bidding $1.50 or less. At scale, that gap isn't a rounding error.

Best Practice: Calculate a weighted Quality Score for your account by multiplying each keyword's QS by its impressions, summing the result, then dividing by total impressions. Accounts with a weighted average below 6 almost always have significant efficiency headroom before you need to touch bids.
---

Does Smart Bidding make Quality Score irrelevant?

Smart Bidding strategies — Maximize Conversions, Maximize Conversion Value, and their target-based variants (Target CPA and Target ROAS) — do not override quality; they amplify whatever quality foundation already exists. [2]

When quality components are strong, the algorithm wins the right auctions at a lower cost floor. When they're weak, the algorithm faces two bad options: overpay to stay competitive, or pull back impression share because it cannot hit your performance targets at the prices the auction requires. In accounts I've managed, launching Target CPA on campaigns with widespread Quality Scores below 5 has repeatedly produced dramatic impression share collapse — not because the algorithm was broken, but because it was correctly pricing itself out of auctions it couldn't win efficiently.

Key Insight: Smart Bidding sets its efficiency ceiling based on the quality foundation you've already built. High Quality Scores give the algorithm a lower cost floor to work from. Low Quality Scores raise that floor, forcing the algorithm to either overpay or exit auctions.
Common Mistake: Launching Maximize Conversions with a Target CPA on campaigns with widespread Quality Scores below 5. The algorithm won't fix structural relevance problems — it will pay more to compensate for them, burning budget while you troubleshoot why the target isn't being hit. Fix quality first, then introduce the target.

Note: Enhanced CPC was retired for Search and Display campaigns in 2025. The current bidding ladder is Manual CPC → Maximize Conversions → Maximize Conversions with Target CPA / Maximize Conversion Value with Target ROAS. If you're still seeing eCPC references in older guides, they no longer apply.

---

How do you improve each Quality Score component?

Expected Click-Through Rate

eCTR measures whether your ads outperform the historical CTR baseline for that keyword across all advertisers — it is a relevance signal, not a popularity contest. Tactics that reliably move it:

If you're seeing low Quality Score alongside a high conversion rate, eCTR is usually the culprit — your landing page works, but your ads aren't compelling enough relative to competitors in that auction.

Ad Relevance

Ad Relevance measures how closely your copy aligns with the query. The fix is structural:

Landing Page Experience

This is the component with the highest upside in most accounts I audit — and the most neglected. Google evaluates it based on content relevance to the ad and query, page load speed (especially on mobile), ease of navigation, and trustworthiness signals. [1]

A "Below Average" landing page experience rating can single-handedly suppress an otherwise solid Quality Score. Mobile page speed improvements alone have moved dozens of keywords from QS 5 to QS 7–8 in accounts I manage, producing CPC reductions of 15–22% within weeks.

Best Practice: Run your key landing page URLs through Google's PageSpeed Insights and target a mobile score above 70. Aim for pages loading in under 3 seconds on a simulated 4G connection. Every meaningful reduction in Time to Interactive typically correlates with Landing Page Experience improvements in Google's quality evaluation.
Common Mistake: Sending all traffic — regardless of product, intent, or query — to your homepage. Homepage landing pages almost universally score "Below Average" for Landing Page Experience because they lack the specific, query-relevant content Google expects. Use dedicated, intent-matched landing pages.
---

When does Quality Score matter less?

There are genuine scenarios where QS is less actionable as a primary lever — but "less actionable" is not the same as "irrelevant."

For a deeper look at how QS behaves in edge cases, the discussion on whether Quality Score is completely effed covers some of the structural frustrations practitioners run into.

---

What to do next

  1. Build a weighted Quality Score baseline today. Export your keyword data, multiply each keyword's QS by its impressions, sum the results, and divide by total impressions. If the weighted average is below 6, you have significant efficiency headroom before touching bids. Use our 250-point Google Ads audit engine to surface QS issues alongside other structural problems in one pass.
  2. Fix Landing Page Experience first. Run your top 10 landing page URLs through PageSpeed Insights. If mobile scores are below 60, this is your highest-leverage Quality Score improvement — often fixable in days. Replace homepage destinations with dedicated, intent-matched pages.
  3. Audit ad group structure for relevance. If any ad group contains more than 15–20 keywords spanning multiple intents, split it. Tighter theming directly improves both Ad Relevance and eCTR ratings.
  4. Don't launch Smart Bidding on low-quality campaigns. If your weighted QS is below 5, spend 30–60 days improving structure and landing pages on Manual CPC before transitioning to Maximize Conversions or adding a Target CPA. The algorithm needs a healthy quality baseline to operate efficiently. [2]
  5. Treat Performance Max asset ratings as your PMax Quality Score. Any asset group with "Low"-rated assets should be your PMax optimization priority — the same underlying principle applies even without traditional keyword-level scoring. [3]

For ongoing bidding and Quality Score optimization guidance, browse all Bidding & Smart Bidding answers or run your account through Buddy, the AI Google Ads agent for a prioritized action list.

---

Frequently asked questions

Can a keyword with a low Quality Score still convert profitably?

Yes — and this causes real confusion. A QS 4 keyword can produce conversions, but you're paying a CPC premium of 10–25% or more compared to what a higher-quality competitor pays for the same placement. The question isn't whether it converts; it's whether the inflated cost leaves room for a profitable return. If margins are thin, that premium can be the difference between a viable and an unviable channel.

How long does it take for Quality Score improvements to show up?

The 1–10 score shown in the interface updates periodically and can lag weeks behind actual changes. Auction-time quality signals, however, respond faster — landing page speed improvements or ad copy rewrites can influence real auction performance within days, even if the displayed score takes longer to reflect the change. Track CPC trends and impression share alongside QS to see the full picture.

Should I pause keywords with Quality Score 1–3?

Not automatically — but keywords stuck at QS 1–3 with significant impression volume are actively raising your cost-per-conversion across the account. First, diagnose which component is rated Below Average. If it's Landing Page Experience or Ad Relevance, fix the structural mismatch before pausing. If the keyword has high impressions, low QS, and low conversion value, pausing or restructuring is often the right call. Never pause on QS alone without checking conversion data.

Does Quality Score affect Google Shopping or Performance Max campaigns?

Traditional keyword-level Quality Score applies only to Search campaigns. Shopping ads use a product feed quality and landing page relevance evaluation that operates differently. Performance Max doesn't expose Quality Scores at all, but asset quality ratings — Low, Good, or Best — serve the same diagnostic function. Poor asset ratings in PMax correlate with reduced auction competitiveness, the same way low QS does in Search.

Is there a Quality Score threshold I should hit before switching to Target CPA?

There's no official threshold, but in practice, accounts with a weighted average Quality Score below 5 consistently struggle when Target CPA is introduced — the algorithm either overpays or retreats from auctions to protect the target. A weighted average of 6 or above across your campaign's keywords is a reasonable readiness signal. Pair that with sufficient conversion volume (typically 30–50 conversions in the past 30 days) before adding the target. [5]

Does the low Quality Score penalty still apply the same way it did historically?

The concept of a "penalty" is a simplification. What actually happens is that low quality raises the minimum bid required to enter an auction and reduces your Ad Rank relative to competitors for the same bid. This mechanism hasn't changed — it's become more sophisticated, not less punishing. The CPC premium for QS 1–3 keywords is steeper in a Smart Bidding-dominated auction landscape because the algorithm's efficiency depends on quality to function correctly.

References

  1. Google Ads Help. “About Quality Score for Search campaigns.” Accessed Nov 11, 2026.
  2. Google Ads Help. “About Smart Bidding.” Accessed Nov 11, 2026.
  3. Google Ads Help. “About Performance Max campaigns.” Accessed Nov 11, 2026.
  4. Google Ads Help. “About Ad Rank.” Accessed Nov 11, 2026.
  5. Google Ads Help. “About Target CPA bidding.” Accessed Nov 11, 2026.
  6. Original community discussion: r/PPC thread on Reddit.

Related Reading

AI Disclosure: This article was generated with AI assistance based on a community discussion on Reddit r/PPC. Expert analysis and practitioner perspective by John Williams, Founder, AHMEEGO · Google Ads Practitioner with $350M+ in managed Google Ads spend. AI was used to draft and structure the content; all strategic recommendations reflect real campaign experience.