The ideal RSA structure in 2026 centers on thematic ad groups of 8–15 intent-aligned keywords, a full 15-headline asset pool covering at least five distinct angles (keyword relevance, value proposition, social proof, CTA, and objection handling), all four description slots filled, and pinning kept to genuine compliance needs only. Ultra-tight SKAGs starve the machine learning system of the signal it needs to optimize asset combinations.
Single Keyword Ad Groups (SKAGs) were designed for a world of static Expanded Text Ads, where every word in the ad was set by the advertiser. That world ended when Google retired ETAs — they can no longer be created or edited. RSAs work on fundamentally different logic: Google dynamically assembles combinations from your asset pool, with up to 43,680 possible headline and description combinations available from a full 15-headline, 4-description set. [1] A single keyword generating a few hundred impressions per month gives the algorithm almost nothing to work with. The question that came up in the r/PPC community — whether tight SKAGs still make sense in 2026 — has a clear answer: they actively hurt RSA performance by starving the system of the query diversity it needs to learn.
The practical floor for meaningful RSA optimization, based on accounts I manage across multiple verticals, is roughly 100–150 impressions per week, with a target of 50+ clicks per month per ad group. Below that threshold, serving decisions for asset combinations are effectively random.
In practice, 8–15 intent-aligned keywords per ad group hits the right balance — enough query diversity for creative learning, tight enough to keep messaging coherent. [2] The number matters less than intent coherence. A group covering [project management software], [project management tool], [best project management app], and [project tracking software] is thematically sound. Mixing bottom-funnel transactional queries with high-funnel informational ones in the same group creates creative tension no RSA can resolve cleanly. For more on structuring your overall account, see practitioners' preferred Google Ads structures.
| Approach | Keywords / Ad Group | RSA Learning Speed | Creative Flexibility | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SKAG (Legacy) | 1–2 | Very Slow / None | Low | ETAs (retired) |
| Tight Thematic | 3–7 | Moderate | Medium | Low-volume niches |
| Broader Thematic | 8–15 | Fast | High | Most accounts in 2026 |
| Consolidated (STAG-style) | 15+ | Fastest | Highest | Smart Bidding, high volume |
Most practitioners either write 15 headlines that all say roughly the same thing — wasted opportunity — or write 15 that are so varied they produce incoherent combinations. The goal is structured variety: different angles, same core value proposition. [3] Here is the asset breakdown I use across high-spend accounts:
For a deeper look at how headline count and variety affect performance, see the RSA headline and description count breakdown. You can also run your drafts through the creative asset validator before uploading.
With four description slots and 90 characters each, Google typically shows two at a time, so each description must stand alone as a compelling statement. [1] Write each description around a distinct pillar: one for features, one for benefits, one for trust/social proof, and one for a clear call to action with any relevant offer. Avoid writing four descriptions that all say the same thing in slightly different words.
Pinning should be the exception, not the default. Locking headlines to specific positions reduces the combinations Google can test, typically lowers Ad Strength scores, and limits what the algorithm can learn. [4] Legitimate use cases include legal or compliance disclosures that must always appear, strict brand name formatting requirements in position 1, and time-sensitive promotions with exact expiration dates.
If you must pin, limit it to one or two headlines and leave all remaining positions open. Pinning position 1 and position 2 while leaving position 3 flexible is a reasonable compromise for brand-sensitive accounts. Pinning all three positions effectively recreates an Expanded Text Ad — a format that is now retired for good reason. For more context on how Google is evolving RSA headline display, see what's changing with RSA headline serving.
Ad Strength is a useful diagnostic, not a performance guarantee. [4] "Excellent" Ad Strength correlates in aggregate with better impression share, but conversion data always takes precedence. I have seen "Poor"-rated RSAs outperform "Excellent" ones when the lower-rated ad had tighter, more compelling copy for a specific audience.
What Ad Strength actually measures: asset variety and uniqueness, keyword inclusion in headlines and descriptions, and whether all 15 headline and 4 description slots are filled. Use it to identify obvious gaps in asset diversity — for example, if all your headlines are too similar — but make optimization decisions based on actual CPA, conversion rate, and ROAS from asset performance reports. For a practitioner-focused breakdown of Ad Strength trade-offs, see best practices for RSA Ad Strength.
Google labels individual assets as "Best," "Good," "Low," or "Unrated." [5] Here is a practical framework for each:
The structural trend in 2026 is consolidation: fewer campaigns with more ad groups, rather than dozens of micro-campaigns segmented by device, match type, or minor keyword variation. Smart Bidding and audience signals handle much of the segmentation that previously required structural separation. For accounts generating >50 conversions per month at the campaign level, Broad Match paired with Maximize Conversions (or Maximize Conversion Value) frequently outperforms Phrase and Exact-only structures — because Broad Match feeds RSA creative learning with more query variety. [6]
Note: Enhanced CPC was retired for Search campaigns in 2025. The current bidding ladder is Manual CPC → Maximize Conversions → Maximize Conversions with a Target CPA, or Maximize Conversion Value with a Target ROAS. Target CPA and Target ROAS are now optional targets set within those strategies, not standalone bid types.
A practical match type framework for most accounts:
Use the keyword and landing page analyzer to audit intent alignment across your ad groups before consolidating or expanding match types.
Yes, but accept the trade-off: very tight ad groups with minimal impressions give Google's RSA system almost no data to optimize asset combinations. For genuinely low-volume, high-value terms, the practical solution is to use Exact or Phrase match, write the tightest possible asset pool for that intent, and monitor asset labels patiently — but do not expect the algorithm to do much creative optimization on thin data.
Write every headline so it makes grammatical and logical sense in any position alongside any other headline. Avoid headlines that only make sense next to a specific other headline. Test your combinations mentally: if headline A and headline B appear together, does the ad still read as a coherent message? A framework for RSA copywriting can help structure this process systematically.
No. Ad Rank is determined by bid, Quality Score components (expected click-through rate, ad relevance, landing page experience), and auction-time signals — not Ad Strength. [6] Ad Strength is an editorial quality signal that correlates with better performance in aggregate, but it does not feed directly into the Ad Rank formula. Optimizing for conversion rate and relevance matters more than chasing the "Excellent" label.
Google allows up to three RSAs per ad group and recommends at least two so the system can run internal variation testing. [1] In most accounts I manage, two RSAs per ad group — one primary and one experimental — provides enough testing surface without fragmenting impression data. Running only one RSA per ad group limits learning; running three is rarely necessary unless you have very high ad group volume.
Every asset change resets some of the learning the algorithm has accumulated for that combination. Changing too many assets at once makes it impossible to attribute performance shifts to any specific change. The practical rule: swap no more than 3–4 assets at a time, wait at least 45–60 days for labels to stabilize, and always export your current "Best" assets before editing so you do not accidentally remove a top performer.
Yes — there are documented cases of RSA headlines being surfaced in non-standard formats, including sitelink-style displays. Google is continuing to experiment with how RSA assets are rendered across surfaces. For current observations on this, see how Google Ads is showing RSA headlines as sitelinks. This reinforces writing every headline as a standalone statement that works in any context.
More answers in this topic: Ad Copy & Creative